Thank you for the advice, guys! I think the reason I get upset is because Daisy, the female, REALLY doesn't like it. She meows weirdly and then will hiss at him to get off, and this usually sparks a tussle between them, resulting in one or the other getting all puffy and upset.
Well...that and the fact that I think of them as my babies...and yes, I realize they're animals, but still, you know? I just feel like I'm watching something...I shouldn't be seeing.
They both do the whole "mush-mush" thing on particular blankies, but that seems to be more of a comfort thing for them.
Why do you think he ONLY does this when he's just woken up?