My 5yr old female GSD Gypsey and is very food orientated (arnt most of them lol) Will when given a doggy treat by other dog oweners we might meet sit and look pretty even give the paw, But upon being given the treat will drop it from her mouth I then pick it up and give it to her when upon she will eat it, I have not taught her to do this and really think shes a clever girl by making shure I have said its ok to eat it just amazes me that shes prepared to do this because as I've already said shes typically a food orientated dog lol