Amy, my Eskimo loves the Turkey and then the Caribou Northern Biscuits - well, frankly, if he doesn't like a cookie the store will reconsider re-ordering. I have avoided the Peanut Butter because he is a smooth operator - although I am sure that in cookie form it would not be the same as in a Kong. Does it leave Peanut Butter breath? I know they are wheat free which is important for this little girly guy. He could be the "face" of Northern Biscuits.