I feed him a little in a.m. but before that he goes outside for pee. I allow him as much water first thing and then remove for remainder of day. Now Moses when he pee outside always give praise when I catch him doing inside I take him by scruff of neck and say Bad. When he poo outside I praise him, unfortunately I have not been able to catch him when he does this inside. In any case I always praise him when he does either on our walks with his brother. I caught him pee indoors today he had been reprimanded then we all had gone for a walk and both did busisness and both received praise. I have never had such problems with this ever. Always have been able to train within one week. I figure because as puppy previous owner did not allow them indoors and all were born before snow fall so business outside had been normal for them this could be why I am having such difficulty. I now take both 3 times per day.