It would be if she would pay attention, and she does, at first. Shes very attentive (same as on her walks) but after about 5 mins with these treats she's jumping around, running with her butt tucked under, laying on her back trying to nibble on things and jerky, erradict movements. We've been using them a week after switching to these treats (from another store bought brand she didn't like) and just need something different and figured I would go more organic which is healthier for both of them. My other dog won't eat them.
Thanks for everything but I will look up treats online instead of trying to see what other people may have made. Which is what I thought would have been better for her if people actually made treats themselves and could tell me how it works for them and what they use. I'll just research on my own and see what works for us. :-)